Centre for Maternal, Reproductive and Child Health
  1. The Cherish Project
  2. Infant Mental Health
  3. Pregnancy and Parenting Circles
  4. Scotland Maternity Services Independent Review
  1. About the review
Maternal, Reproductive and Child Health

About the review

This review is being conducted independently, but in accordance with the Principles set out by the Scottish Government.

In accordance with those principles it will take a whole systems approach, make a population-based strategic assessment of current and future needs of the population and be informed by the experiences of women, families and staff throughout. It will be forward-looking to make recommendations for sustainable, safe maternity care.

Listening to experiences

The review will involve detailed analysis of how services are designed and function, at system, board and local levels. Listening to and engagement with parents, advocacy and community organisations is central and should reflect the diversity of experience including those who have suffered harms and loss and also positive care experience.

It will be inclusive of those from more disadvantaged backgrounds, various ethnic groups, urban rural and island populations and gender diversity. Listening to providers at all levels from senior leadership to frontline practitioners across all relevant professional groups, and to students and educators is also central.

Listening, analysing and understanding the experiences of women, birthing people, partners, families and maternity staff is an important part of the scope of the review. This will enable us to draw out recurrent themes in their stories, learn lessons from their experiences, and ensure that the reporting and recommendations inform and contribute to an effective, sustainable and equitable improvement journey.

We have set out in our Methodology and Public Engagement approach the ways in which people can become involved in the review. Women, families and community groups will be involved first through an advisory group which will provide advice and guidance throughout the review process. There will also be larger round-table meetings to capture the wide diversity of experiences and views, and we will hold Listening Meetings in a range of community settings across Scotland.

Listening to women who have experienced loss, harm or trauma and their partners or families is an important part of the scope of this review. We will be offering individual interviews for those who wish this, with a trauma-informed approach sensitive to the fact parents want lessons to be drawn from their experiences, while telling their stories can be difficult and painful. See the public engagement  page for more information.

A forward-looking review

The principles set out for this review include a forward-looking approach. A forward-looking approach means not only learning from problems and harms but also from positive examples of good practice to inform future improvements.

It aims for understanding of past and current problems to draw lessons for change. Understanding of services that are functioning well, in addition to problems within services, is part of the picture to draw lessons for sustainable improvement, quality and safety. It will require analysis of large-scale and routine data as well as more local and qualitative data to underpin these aims.

Aim of the review

The aim of this review is to examine maternity services, drawing in a range of evidence, perspectives and experience to understand factors that influence quality and safety of care, experiences, outcomes and wellbeing of those who use the service and those who provide it.

The resulting report will present an analysis and recommendations for improvement. Recommendations may highlight key aspects of the maternity system which require change. It will also identify examples of good practice, and what is needed to sustain and adapt or replicate these nationally.

Scope of the review

All levels of service will be in view, from individual experiences to ways in which services are designed, structured and delivered, also taking into account geographical, social and policy context. The review period is nine months, with submission of the report after a further month.

The policy and socio-economic context will continue to change during this period, meaning that any contextual changes should also be taken into consideration. Improvement workstreams that are already in process or planned, including service action plans following Healthcare Improvement Scotland inspections will not be paused pending the review and will also be taken into consideration in the analysis.

The review scope is maternity services and does not extend to a review of neonatal services, or of other services that intersect with maternity care. Nonetheless, the intersections with neonatal services, pre-conception, miscarriage care, assisted reproduction and other areas of women’s health are significant and will be taken into full consideration. All stages of maternity care including postnatal care will be in view. Key services that also intersect with maternity, such as ambulance services and perinatal mental health services will also be considered, but with a clear maternity services focus.

Quality, experience and outcomes of maternity care have long-term, even life-long and intergenerational consequences.  The review scope does not include a focus on other services that provide care following discharge from maternity services, such as health visiting, paediatric or other health or care services, but the scope and focus will take into account the central importance of maternity for health and wellbeing in the longer term.

The focus is on Scotland’s maternity services, but lessons may be drawn from the other UK nations and from countries with comparable geography, populations and overarching health systems (e.g. Denmark, Sweden, Norway, New Zealand).

What the review does not cover

The review scope and purpose differs from an investigation or inquiry in important ways and does not duplicate the work of Healthcare Improvement Scotland inspections. It does not include investigation of individual cases or clinical case reviews, or inspection or investigation of specific services.

The ways in which other processes such as investigations, case reviews and support for parents function and the impact of these will, however, be in scope and will be important to inform improvement recommendations.

This includes examination of the systems that investigate, provide support and redress for those who experience loss or harm, and any factors that may affect the provision of appropriate care and support.

To contact the review team please email ScotlandMaternityReview@citystgeorges.ac.uk.